Protocolbot
6e7c03b373
CRITICAL (3 files replaced): - Removed pipe-ceremony (sacred Anishinaabe ceremony) - Removed condolence-ceremony (restricted Haudenosaunee ritual) - Removed land-back-rematriation-gathering (named living Ohlone individuals) - Added: indigenous-council-circle, grief-tending-council, land-stewardship-council (non-sacred governance protocols) - Added: truth-and-reconciliation-circle (to replace removed duplicate) HIGH (6 fixes): - Palaver Tree: removed 'West African' from title - Cabildo Council: renamed from generic 'Community Council' - Brotherhood Reasoning: removed exoticizing 'ganja-assisted' framing - Talking Stick Circle: broadened from Ohlone-specific to pan-Indigenous - Buddhist Debate: replaced controversial NKT source with Sera Monastery - Oxford Citizens' Assembly: corrected attribution to Oxford City Council MEDIUM (11 fixes): - Nyabinghi: noted East African roots of the term - Shellmound Walk: reframed as contemporary practice - Jmaa/Imbizo/Ronda: noted gender evolution toward inclusion - Utari: clarified as kin network term, not practice name - Samata Melan: clarified as Ambedkarite-inspired contemporary practice - Ancestor Reverence: removed defensive 'not superstition' framing - Bod Kyi Gtam: improved source specificity - Restorative Conference: named specific Indigenous traditions - Open Space: specified Liberia context for Owen's inspiration LOW (14 fixes): - Added macrons to Māori words in pōwhiri - Contextualized coca leaf in ayni/minga - Added specific tags (fijian, tongan, samoan) to talanoa - Improved source URLs for yangban, xeer, indaba, meidung - Removed duplicate appreciative-apology (kept the better version) - Clarified council-practice as contemporary synthesis 99 files changed, net 100 protocols in library.
46 lines
2.1 KiB
YAML
46 lines
2.1 KiB
YAML
id: yangban-council-deliberation
|
|
title: Yangban Council Deliberation
|
|
description: >-
|
|
A Joseon-dynasty Korean practice of council deliberation among the
|
|
yangban (scholar-official) class, in which officials discussed policy
|
|
with reference to Confucian texts and precedent, seeking consensus that
|
|
balanced royal authority with ministerial judgment. Rooted in Korean
|
|
Confucian governance from the 14th to 19th centuries.
|
|
source: Joseon Dynasty governance / Korean Confucian tradition
|
|
source_url: http://db.history.go.kr/
|
|
tags: [korean, joseon, yangban, confucian, governance, council]
|
|
forked_from: null
|
|
image: null
|
|
steps:
|
|
- headline: Convene the council
|
|
description: >-
|
|
Senior officials (yangban) convene, often at the king's request or on
|
|
a matter of state. The council deliberates in the presence of
|
|
Confucian texts and court records.
|
|
- headline: Cite precedent and text
|
|
description: >-
|
|
Each official grounds their position in Confucian classics and in
|
|
precedent from prior reigns. Argument proceeds by appeal to text and
|
|
history, not by personal preference alone.
|
|
- headline: Deliberate to consensus
|
|
description: >-
|
|
The council deliberates toward a consensus that balances the king's
|
|
authority with the officials' collective judgment. Strong dissent
|
|
is recorded and weighed.
|
|
- headline: Memorialise the king
|
|
description: >-
|
|
The council's consensus, with any dissent, is memorialised to the
|
|
king as a written memorial. The king may accept, modify, or reject,
|
|
but the memorial carries the council's weight.
|
|
- headline: Record for precedent
|
|
description: >-
|
|
The deliberation and outcome are recorded in the court annals, so
|
|
future councils may cite them as precedent.
|
|
outcome: >-
|
|
Policy is deliberated by scholar-officials with reference to text and
|
|
precedent, producing a memorial that balances royal authority with
|
|
ministerial judgment.
|
|
practice: >-
|
|
The citation of text and precedent is the discipline — it binds
|
|
argument to shared sources. Without it, deliberation becomes assertion.
|
|
The record for precedent makes the council's work cumulative. |