Browse Source

Added to FAQ, removed variables from templates

Nathan Schneider 5 years ago
parent
commit
60387881e9
3 changed files with 11 additions and 6 deletions
  1. 9 4
      _about/faq.md
  2. 1 1
      _rules/petition.md
  3. 1 1
      _rules/self-appointed_board.md

+ 9 - 4
_about/faq.md

@@ -12,6 +12,14 @@ CommunityRule is focused on an often-missing component in online communities: th
 
 
 The purpose of CommunityRule is to make it easier for communities to efficiently replace the default feudalism with a more appropriate and accountable governance system, or Rule. Communities can then use their preferred Rule to fill in other layers of the stack through an explicit process.
 The purpose of CommunityRule is to make it easier for communities to efficiently replace the default feudalism with a more appropriate and accountable governance system, or Rule. Communities can then use their preferred Rule to fill in other layers of the stack through an explicit process.
 
 
+**Why does focusing on the governance layer seem important? Haven't online communities gotten along fine so far?**
+
+This project emerged out of a series of research projects. The first is called "[Admins, Mods, and Benevolent Dictators for Life: The Implicit Feudalism of Online Communities](https://osf.io/gxu3a/?view_only=11c9e93011df4865951f2056a64f5938)," and it traces the quiet persistence of surprisingly undemocratic tool-sets on platforms for online communities. This revealed that fostering democracy online tends to require extra work when compared to more feudal, non-democratic governance. Through the [Metagovernance Project](http://metagov.org/), this led to an ambitious proposal for software development, "[Modular Politics](https://ntnsndr.in/modular-politics)." CommunityRule is a more modest prototype, aiming to fill the gaps in online governance with a simple, natural-language toolkit in lieu of a more sophisticated software framework. 
+
+**What's with the name "Rule"? Aren't these lists of multiple rules?**
+
+The use of "Rule" in the singular is a tribute to the idiom used for the governance documents of medieval Latin monastic communities, which go by the name *Regula*. These are some of the oldest governing documents still in active use, and they serve the dual purposes of governance and spiritual guidance.
+
 **What kinds of projects do you take inspiration from?**
 **What kinds of projects do you take inspiration from?**
 
 
 A bunch of stuff, including but not limited to these:
 A bunch of stuff, including but not limited to these:
@@ -34,9 +42,6 @@ A bunch of stuff, including but not limited to these:
     - [Creative Commons](https://creativecommons.org/)
     - [Creative Commons](https://creativecommons.org/)
     - [License Zero](https://licensezero.com/)
     - [License Zero](https://licensezero.com/)
     - [Polyform Project](https://polyformproject.org/)
     - [Polyform Project](https://polyformproject.org/)
-* [Metagovernance Project](http://metagov.org/)
-    - "[Admins, Mods, and Benevolent Dictators for Life](https://osf.io/gxu3a/?view_only=11c9e93011df4865951f2056a64f5938)"
-    - "[Modular Politics](https://ntnsndr.in/modular-politics)"
 * Monastic rules
 * Monastic rules
     - Rule of St. Augustine
     - Rule of St. Augustine
     - Rule of St. Benedict
     - Rule of St. Benedict
@@ -54,7 +59,7 @@ A bunch of stuff, including but not limited to these:
 Funny you mention it. Right here:
 Funny you mention it. Right here:
 
 
 * Javascript output button
 * Javascript output button
-    - Could it somehow output to IPFS?
+    - Could it output to IPFS or some other persisitent storage medium?
 * Rules (ready-to-deploy presets)
 * Rules (ready-to-deploy presets)
     - Brand preset rules as CommunityRule rules with tools to create badges out of them
     - Brand preset rules as CommunityRule rules with tools to create badges out of them
 * Less textual, more visual header for Rule pages
 * Less textual, more visual header for Rule pages

+ 1 - 1
_rules/petition.md

@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ structure: All members have potentially equal voice in a direct democracy. Volun
 rights: All members have the right to initiate peitions, sign them, and vote in resulting referendums.
 rights: All members have the right to initiate peitions, sign them, and vote in resulting referendums.
 membership:
 membership:
 removal: A member may be removed if a petition for their removal passes.
 removal: A member may be removed if a petition for their removal passes.
-decision: All policies and governance actions in the community are initiated by petition. Any member can start a petition. If $NUMBER percent of the membership signs it, the content of the petition becomes a referendum in which all members are invited to vote. If 2/3 of the votes are in favor of the petition after 1 week, it passes.
+decision: All policies and governance actions in the community are initiated by petition. Any member can start a petition. If 1/3 of the membership signs it, the content of the petition becomes a referendum in which all members are invited to vote. If 2/3 of the votes are in favor of the petition after 1 week, it passes.
 deliberation: When a petition goes before the community, the petitioner must organize at least one synchronous discussion session open to all members in the first half of the voting period.
 deliberation: When a petition goes before the community, the petitioner must organize at least one synchronous discussion session open to all members in the first half of the voting period.
 implementation: Administrators are responsible for carrying out the outcomes of the petition process.
 implementation: Administrators are responsible for carrying out the outcomes of the petition process.
 oversight: The petition process may be used to remove administrators if they are deemed non-compliant with community policies, and the petition process may also be used to reverse the outcomes of previous processes.
 oversight: The petition process may be used to remove administrators if they are deemed non-compliant with community policies, and the petition process may also be used to reverse the outcomes of previous processes.

+ 1 - 1
_rules/self-appointed_board.md

@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ structure: An annually self-appointed board of no more than 5 members determines
 rights: The board is expected to operate according to this Rule and the explicit agreements it has created.
 rights: The board is expected to operate according to this Rule and the explicit agreements it has created.
 membership:
 membership:
 removal:
 removal:
-decision: Each year, on $DATE, current board members elect the board members for the subsequent year. At least 51% of board members must vote to approve a proposal in order for it to become a community agreement.
+decision: Each year current board members elect the board members for the subsequent year. At least 51% of board members must vote to approve a proposal in order for it to become a community agreement.
 implementation: Board members or their designees are responsible for implementing agreements, and the board should have access to the means to implement the agreements that it has approved.
 implementation: Board members or their designees are responsible for implementing agreements, and the board should have access to the means to implement the agreements that it has approved.
 oversight: Community members unhappy with the board's implementation with the agreements may voice their concerns to individual board members or in the community at large.
 oversight: Community members unhappy with the board's implementation with the agreements may voice their concerns to individual board members or in the community at large.
 limits: Board members can serve an unlimited number of 1-year terms.
 limits: Board members can serve an unlimited number of 1-year terms.